MISCONCEPTION:ARJUN DID NOT DESTROY SEVEN AKSHONI ARMY ON DAY 14
THIS THREAD IS DIVIDED INTO TWO PARTS-
PART 1) PROOFS FROM KMG,GEETA PRESS THAT ARJUN DESTROYED 7 AKSHONIS
PART 2) AKSHONI CALCULATIONS MISINTERPRETATION
--------------------
PART 1) PROOFS FROM KMG AND GEETA PRESS THAT ARJUN DESTROYED 7 AKSHONIS
Its clearly written in KMG translation that Arjun destroyed 7 Akshoni kuru army on Day 14 as told by Duryodhan.
Narrative:
(Duryodhan To Drona)
Another disciple of thine, viz., the invincible Savyasachin, having slain #seven.#Akshauhinis of troops hath despatched king Jayadratha to Yama's abode.
But our Karna fans can't digest this fact so as usual they started using their brains,which they unfortunately lack Karna fans say that these are two separate lines and gave a funny justification for it.LOL
NOW READ THE HINDI TRANSLATION OF THESE LINES FROM GEETA PRESS,CLEARLY WRITTEN THAT ARJUN DESTROYED 7 AKSHONI,NO FULL STOP TO CAUSE CONFUSION-
सव्यसाची अर्जुनने मेरी सात अक्षौहिणी सेनाओंका संहार करके आपके दूसरे दुर्धर्ष शिष्य राजा जयद्रथको भी मार डाला है ।
Screenshot with Sanskrit Slokas - 
http://bit.ly/1r37SkV
http://bit.ly/1r37SkV
I hope now the confusion of full stops and semi colens is finished. Clearly written in Hindi and Sanskrit Slokas also that Arjun destroyed seven Akshonis of Army that day.
--------------------
EVEN SANJAY TELLS DHRITRASHTRA THAT TOTAL EIGHT AKSHONIS OF ARMY HAS BEEN DESTROYED THAT DAY-
Narrative:
Thy sons with their followers, O king, thus, came to know subsequently that the darkness, they had seen, had all been an illusion produced by Vasudeva. Even thus, O king, was thy son-in-law, the ruler of the Sindhus, having caused #eight #Akshauhinis to be slaughtered, himself slain by Partha of inconceivable energy.
AS YOU ALL CAN READ,CLEARLY WRITTEN THAT EIGHT AKSHONIS WERE DESTROYED IN AN ATTEMPT TO PROTECT JAYADRATH.SO IN THOSE,SEVEN WERE DESTROYED BY ARJUN(AS TOLD BY DURYODHAN) AND ONE BY BHIMA,SATYAKI AND OTHERS.
NOW KARNA FANS,BEFORE CALLING SANJAY BAISED,USE SOME COMMON SENSE.SANJAY WAS REPORTING ALL THIS DESTRUCTION TO DHRITRASHTRA,AND DHRITRASHTRA WAS BLIND,HE WAS NOT A FOOL THAT SANJAY WOULD LIE SEVEN AKSHONI DESTRUCTION AND HE WOULD BELEIVE IT.HAD SANJAY REPORTED SUCH A BIG LIE,HE WOULD HAVE BEEN TRAPPED IN HIS OWN LIES LATER .
NEITHER WAS SANJAY BAISED NOR WAS DURYODHAN MAD THAT HE SAID ARJUN DESTROYED SEVEN AKSHONI THAT DAY.
-----------------------------------------
PART 2) AKSHONI CALCULATIONS MISINTERPRETATION -
Karna fans mentioned in their post that when Drona became commander,Kauravs had 9 Akshonis and when Karna became commander,Kauravs had 5 Akshonis,then total Akshonis exhausted in Drona Parva = 4 so its not possible that Arjun Slayed 7 akshoni.
Pandavs followed the standard Akshoni Measure ie, 218700 (Humans + Animals).
CALCULATION- (21870*1 + 21870*3 + 21870*5 + 21870*1) = 218700
But the number of (Humans + Animals) in Kaurav Akshoni were much more,their number was more than 500000.(Calculation Explained at the end of the Post)
SO BASICALLY,PANDAV AKSHONI = 218K AND KAURAV AKSHONI = 500K,
THIS MEANS,
1 KAURAV AKSHONI = 2.29 TIMES PANDAVA AKSHONI(IN WARRIOR STRENGTH)
TOTAL KAURAV AKSHONIS FROM PANDAVA CALCULATION = 2.29*11 = 25
SO KAURAVS HAD MORE THAN THREE TIMES LARGER ARMY COMPARED TO PANDAVS,THIS CAN BE PROVED FROM DURYODHAN'S STATEMENT IN UDYOGA PARVA ALSO,
DURYODHAN TELLING DHRITRASHTRA THAT HIS ARMY EXCEEDS PANDAVS ARMY BY THREE TIMES-
NARRATIVE:
My army, O king, exceedeth that of the foe by a #third. Besides, O Bharata, I know that the enemy hath many defects, while mine, O lord, are endued with many good virtues.
AS YOU ALL CAN READ,DURYODHAN SAYS THAT HIS ARMY IS THREE TIMES LARGER THAN PANDAV ARMY.
AS PER DURYODHAN AND SANJAY,ARJUN KILLED 7 AKSHONI ARMY ON DAY 14,SO HERE,THEY MUST BE USING STANDARD AKSHONI CALCULATION,SO AS PER THE KAURAV AKSHONI CALCULATION,THOSE SEVEN AKSHONI WERE EQUAL TO AROUND 3 AKSHONIS(7/2.29 = 3).
CALCULATION OF 500K WARRIORS IN A KAURAV AKSHONI-
PROOF FROM KMG TRANSLATION(SOME CALCULATION NEEDED)-
UDYOGA PARVA,SECTION 156,KURU ARMY DESCRIBED BY VAISAMPAYANA-
Narrative:
Five times fifty men constitute a Patti. Three Pattis make a Senamukha or Gulma. Three Gulmas make a Gana. In Duryodhana's army, there were thousands and hundred of such Ganas consisting of warriors capable of smiting (the foe) and longing for battle. And the mighty-armed king Duryodhana, selecting from among them brave and intelligent warriors, made them the leaders of his troops.
HINDI TRANSLATION AND SANKRIT SLOKAS FOR THE SAME(FROM GEETA PRESS)-
पचपन पैदलोंकी एक टुकड़ीको पत्ति केहते हैं । तीन पत्तियाँ मिलकर एक सेनमुख कहलाती हैं । सेनमुखका ही दूसरा नाम गुल्म है ॥
तीन गुल्म एक गण होता है । दुर्योधनकी सेनाओंमें युद्ध करनेवाले पैदल योद्धाओंके ऐसे-ऐसे गण दस हजारसे भी अधिक थे ॥
Screenshot with Sanskrit Slokas - http://bit.ly/1GvHbJo
http://bit.ly/1GvHbJo
Now if we calculate the strength of Kaurav Akshonis based on this Data-
Number of Ganas in Kuru Army = More than 10000
Number of warriors in each Gana = 55*3*3 = 495
Total Warriors in 11 Akshoni Kuru Army = (10000*495) = 4950000
Total Warriors in 1 Akshoni Kuru Army = 4950000/11 = 450000
THE CALCULATIONS ARE GIVEN ABOVE
Kaurava army had Gana and then the Maharathis. There was no other lower officer rank described in between. Ten thousand Gana units were in Kaurava army, size of which was 49,50,000.
APART FROM THESE,KAURAVS HAD 10,000 SENIOR SERGEANTS AS WELL,THE KAURAVA PRATNA CONTAINING 5000 WARRIORS ETC,ANIMALS ALSO,SO ADDING ALL THESE TOTAL COMES AROUND 500K OR PERHAPS MORE
I HOPE THE LOGIC IS CLEAR NOW,NEITHER SANJAYA WAS LYING NOR DURYODHAN,ARJUN DID KILL 7 AKSHONIS(EQUAL TO THREE KURU AKSHONI) ON DAY 14,AND THE AKSHONI FIGHTING WITH EACH COMMANDER AS TOLD BY LORD KRISHNA ALSO GOES CORRECT FOLLOWING THIS CALCULATION.
No comments:
Post a Comment